GenGrades
EN中文

这篇内容还没有中文版

下面是英文原文。中文版发布后,这里会换成中文。 打开英文页面

Best OpenClaw Alternatives in 2026: 8 Personal AI Agents Compared on Safety, Setup and Cost

阅读约 7 分钟发布于 更新于

Hermes Agent is the best OpenClaw alternative for most people: free, open source, safer by default and able to import an OpenClaw setup in one command. NanoClaw puts every session in a container, ZeroClaw is a tiny sandboxed binary, Claude Cowork suits people who would rather pay than host, and Hostinger is the cheapest way to keep OpenClaw itself.

利益关系说明

None of these products is made by the team behind GenGrades, and none paid to be listed. They are ranked on what matters when leaving OpenClaw: safety defaults, setup effort, chat apps, model choice and cost, how actively each is maintained, and how easily an existing setup moves over. Every fact links to its source.

一览

每款工具最适合什么情况、最便宜的付费方案和免费额度。

  1. 1. Hermes Agent

    Leaving OpenClaw for the closest open-source match with safer defaults

    最便宜的付费方案:
    Free; optional Nous Portal from $20 a month
    免费额度:
    All of it: MIT licence
  2. 2. NanoClaw

    Keeping a bad skill or prompt injection inside a container

    最便宜的付费方案:
    Free; you pay your model provider
    免费额度:
    All of it: MIT licence
  3. 3. ZeroClaw

    A small, sandboxed agent on a cheap VPS or a Raspberry Pi

    最便宜的付费方案:
    Free; you pay your model provider
    免费额度:
    All of it: MIT or Apache-2.0
  4. 4. nanobot

    Python users who want an agent they can install with pip and read

    最便宜的付费方案:
    Free; you pay your model provider
    免费额度:
    All of it: MIT licence
  5. 5. Claude Cowork

    An agent that keeps working while you are away, with nothing to host

    最便宜的付费方案:
    $20 a month (Pro), or $200 a year
    免费额度:
    None: Cowork needs a paid plan
  6. 6. Hostinger Managed OpenClaw

    Keeping OpenClaw itself, running 24/7, for the least money

    最便宜的付费方案:
    $4.99 a month at first, then $11.99 a month
    免费额度:
    None; 30-day money-back guarantee
  7. 7. MaxClaw

    Non-technical users who want an OpenClaw agent in Telegram in seconds

    最便宜的付费方案:
    $19 a month, as shown on the MaxClaw page
    免费额度:
    Free MiniMax Agent credits for logging in daily
  8. 8. MyClaw

    Running OpenClaw or Hermes 24/7 without touching a server

    最便宜的付费方案:
    $29 a month (Lite), or $199 a year
    免费额度:
    No free plan or trial shown

逐款介绍

每款能做什么、要花多少钱、哪里不够好。

  1. 1. Hermes Agent

    Leaving OpenClaw for the closest open-source match with safer defaults
    Hermes Agent's home page, with the one-line terminal install for macOS, Linux and Windows and a cloud deploy option.
    Hermes Agent's home page, with the one-line terminal install for macOS, Linux and Windows and a cloud deploy option.

    来源:hermes-agent.nousresearch.com核对于

    Hermes Agent, from Nous Research, is a free, MIT-licensed personal agent you install on your own computer or server and reach from Telegram, Discord, Slack, WhatsApp, Signal or email. It turns finished tasks into reusable skills, keeps searchable memory, and imports an existing OpenClaw setup with one command. In Kilo's reading of more than 1,300 r/openclaw comments, about 30% of commenters had moved to Hermes and 20% ran both.

    最便宜的付费方案

    Free; optional Nous Portal from $20 a month

    The software costs nothing. Nous Portal Plus ($20 a month) buys $22 of model credits; you can instead bring your own key from OpenRouter, OpenAI or another provider.

    来源:portal.nousresearch.com核对于

    免费额度

    All of it: MIT licence

    Nous Portal also has a $0 tier limited to free models.

    来源:github.com核对于

    Safety defaults

    Risky commands need approval; chat users are denied until allowlisted

    A blocklist (for example rm -rf /) and protected paths such as SSH keys apply even in YOLO mode; unattended runs default to deny.

    来源:hermes-agent.nousresearch.com核对于

    Chat apps

    Telegram, Discord, Slack, WhatsApp, Signal and email

    No iMessage.

    来源:github.com核对于

    GitHub stars (Oct 25)

    About 256.9k

    Latest release v0.22.5 on October 22, 2026.

    来源:github.com核对于

    Moving from OpenClaw

    One command: hermes import-agent openclaw

    A --dry-run option previews the move; --migrate-secrets brings keys across.

    来源:github.com核对于

    优点

    • Imports an existing OpenClaw setup with one command, with a dry run first.
    • Safer out of the box than OpenClaw: dangerous commands go through an approval check and strangers cannot message it until you allow them.
    • By far the largest community of these alternatives, about 256,900 GitHub stars, and a new release on October 22, 2026.

    要注意

    • Its Skills Guard scanner had an injection flaw with a public exploit (CVE-2026-9353, rated 7.3) until version 0.15.0.
    • Fewer chat apps than OpenClaw, and no iMessage.
    • Users report its self-improvement loop can call a failed task a success, and about 15% of commenters in Kilo's sample suspected coordinated promotion.

    这些情况别选:you need iMessage or OpenClaw's full list of chat apps, or you do not want to use a command line at all.

    The Hermes Agent repository on GitHub on October 25, 2026: MIT licence and about 256.9k stars.
    The Hermes Agent repository on GitHub on October 25, 2026: MIT licence and about 256.9k stars.

    来源:github.com核对于

  2. 2. NanoClaw

    Keeping a bad skill or prompt injection inside a container
    NanoClaw's home page, which describes it as a personal agent that runs in containers.
    NanoClaw's home page, which describes it as a personal agent that runs in containers.

    来源:nanoclaw.dev核对于

    NanoClaw is a small open-source assistant from NanoCo that runs every agent session in its own Docker container, which sees only the folders you mount, while API keys stay in a vault outside it. You reach it from WhatsApp, Telegram, Slack, iMessage, Signal and more, and you customise it by changing code in your own copy rather than settings.

    最便宜的付费方案

    Free; you pay your model provider

    There is no paid or hosted NanoClaw plan. Claude is the default model, Codex is offered at setup and other providers come through skills; local Ollama models cost nothing.

    来源:nanoclaw.dev核对于

    免费额度

    All of it: MIT licence

    来源:github.com核对于

    Safety defaults

    Every session in an unprivileged Docker container

    Keys are injected at request time from the OneCLI vault, so agents never hold them. Network lockdown and human approvals are optional.

    来源:nanoclaw.dev核对于

    Chat apps

    WhatsApp, Telegram, Slack, Discord, iMessage, Signal, Teams and more

    Each one is added with an /add-<channel> skill.

    来源:nanoclaw.dev核对于

    GitHub stars (Oct 25)

    About 31.0k

    Latest release v2026.10.0 on October 9, 2026.

    来源:github.com核对于

    优点

    • Isolation by default: a skill gone wrong is confined to its container and the folders you gave it.
    • Agents never see raw API keys.
    • Answers in iMessage and Signal as well as WhatsApp and Telegram, and is no longer tied to Claude.

    要注意

    • Harder to set up: it needs Docker, Node.js and pnpm, and openclawvps.io scored its setup 2 out of 5.
    • Changing how it works means editing code in your copy, with Claude Code's help, not switching settings.
    • VentureBeat noted in February 2026 that its security claims come from its creator, with no independent audit.

    这些情况别选:you want to configure your assistant through settings rather than code, or you do not want Docker on your machine.

    The NanoClaw repository (nanocoai/nanoclaw) on GitHub: MIT licence and about 31k stars.
    The NanoClaw repository (nanocoai/nanoclaw) on GitHub: MIT licence and about 31k stars.

    来源:github.com核对于

  3. 3. ZeroClaw

    A small, sandboxed agent on a cheap VPS or a Raspberry Pi
    ZeroClaw's official site, zeroclaw.com: version 0.8.6, the one-line installer and the MIT or Apache-2.0 licence.
    ZeroClaw's official site, zeroclaw.com: version 0.8.6, the one-line installer and the MIT or Apache-2.0 licence.

    来源:zeroclaw.com核对于

    ZeroClaw is a personal agent shipped as one Rust binary that runs on Linux, macOS, Windows and small boards and connects to more than 70 model providers and 30 chat channels. Its default autonomy level asks before medium-risk actions and blocks high-risk ones inside an OS sandbox. Only zeroclaw.com and github.com/zeroclaw-labs/zeroclaw are official: the project warns that look-alike repositories and domains impersonate it.

    最便宜的付费方案

    Free; you pay your model provider

    No subscription or hosted seat; local models through Ollama or llama.cpp cost nothing.

    来源:zeroclaw.com核对于

    免费额度

    All of it: MIT or Apache-2.0

    来源:github.com核对于

    Safety defaults

    Approval for medium-risk actions; high-risk ones blocked

    OS sandboxes (Landlock, Bubblewrap, Seatbelt or Docker), command allowlists and workspace scoping; YOLO mode is opt-in.

    来源:github.com核对于

    Chat apps

    30+, including WhatsApp, Telegram, Slack, Signal and iMessage

    来源:zeroclaw.com核对于

    GitHub stars (Oct 25)

    About 33.0k

    Latest release v0.8.6 on October 18, 2026; the project has not reached 1.0.

    来源:github.com核对于

    优点

    • Safe defaults from the first run: approvals and an OS sandbox are on unless you switch them off.
    • One small binary: ZeroClaw says a prebuilt install took 14 seconds and the CLI starts in about 12 ms on Apple Silicon.
    • The widest model choice of the light forks: 70+ providers, hosted or local, with fallback chains.

    要注意

    • Still at version 0.8: plugins and long-running automation are on the roadmap, not finished.
    • Impostor copies exist, and at least one popular GitHub list of OpenClaw alternatives links an unofficial fork.
    • Command line only, with no hosted option.

    这些情况别选:you need a stable 1.0 product, or you want someone else to host it.

    The official ZeroClaw repository, zeroclaw-labs/zeroclaw, on GitHub: about 33.0k stars.
    The official ZeroClaw repository, zeroclaw-labs/zeroclaw, on GitHub: about 33.0k stars.

    来源:github.com核对于

  4. 4. nanobot

    Python users who want an agent they can install with pip and read
    The nanobot repository (HKUDS/nanobot) on GitHub: about 49.3k stars and the project description.
    The nanobot repository (HKUDS/nanobot) on GitHub: about 49.3k stars and the project description.

    来源:github.com核对于

    nanobot, from the HKUDS group on GitHub, is a lightweight self-hosted agent written in Python, with a browser WebUI, memory, MCP tools, scheduled jobs and access from Telegram, Discord, Slack, WeChat, Feishu, Teams and email. It is the most-starred of the light OpenClaw alternatives and the easiest to install: pip or uv, then a setup wizard or the WebUI.

    最便宜的付费方案

    Free; you pay your model provider

    Works with any OpenAI-compatible API, Anthropic, or a local server such as Ollama or vLLM.

    来源:github.com核对于

    免费额度

    All of it: MIT licence

    来源:github.com核对于

    Safety defaults

    Pairing and allowlists per chat app; no container by default

    Project folders can be set to Restricted. Releases v0.3.0 and v0.3.5 tightened allowlist, SSRF and credential handling.

    来源:github.com核对于

    Chat apps

    Telegram, Discord, Slack, WeChat, Feishu, Teams and email

    No WhatsApp or iMessage in today's README.

    来源:github.com核对于

    GitHub stars (Oct 25)

    About 49.3k

    Latest release v0.3.5 on September 15, 2026.

    来源:github.com核对于

    优点

    • The easiest install of the light forks: pip or uv, then a browser WebUI or a setup wizard.
    • A small Python codebase that KDnuggets describes as compact and auditable.
    • Steady security work: v0.3.0 and v0.3.5 closed an allowlist bypass and reduced credential leaks to subprocesses.

    要注意

    • No container isolation by default; it relies on allowlists and folder restrictions.
    • No WhatsApp or iMessage.
    • Its README warns that approving a private sender may not restrict group access everywhere.

    这些情况别选:you need WhatsApp or iMessage, or container isolation out of the box.

  5. 5. Claude Cowork

    An agent that keeps working while you are away, with nothing to host
    Anthropic's Claude Cowork page, which says Cowork works with a paid plan.
    Anthropic's Claude Cowork page, which says Cowork works with a paid plan.

    来源:claude.com核对于

    Claude Cowork is the agent mode in Anthropic's Claude apps: you give it a goal and it works across the folders, apps and connectors you allow, in an isolated cloud environment, including scheduled tasks that run while your laptop is closed. Cowork does not answer in WhatsApp or Telegram; Claude Code's channels feature does, but only while a Claude Code session is running on your computer, and it is a research preview.

    最便宜的付费方案

    $20 a month (Pro), or $200 a year

    Cowork shares Pro's usage limits with chat and Claude Code and uses them faster than chat. Max costs $100 or $200 a month.

    来源:claude.com核对于

    免费额度

    None: Cowork needs a paid plan

    来源:support.claude.com核对于

    Safety defaults

    Isolated cloud environment; only the folders you connect

    Approval modes are Manual, Auto or Skip, and it asks before deleting anything permanently. Anthropic notes isolation does not limit what Claude does with the access you grant.

    来源:support.claude.com核对于

    Chat apps

    None for Cowork; Telegram, Discord or iMessage via Claude Code channels

    Channels work only while the Claude Code session runs, and are a research preview.

    来源:code.claude.com核对于

    Models

    Claude only

    Included in the subscription; you cannot bring another model to Cowork.

    来源:claude.com核对于

    优点

    • Nothing to install on a server or secure yourself.
    • Scheduled tasks run in Anthropic's cloud, so your computer can be off, and tasks can be started from the phone.
    • Access is limited to the folders you connect, with a choice of approval modes.

    要注意

    • Not a chat-app assistant: Cowork lives in Claude's own apps.
    • Claude models only, and multi-step tasks use up plan limits quickly.
    • Sessions cannot be shared with other people.

    这些情况别选:you want to text your assistant on WhatsApp, choose your own model, or keep everything on your own machine.

    Claude Code's channels docs, which mark channels as a research preview that pushes messages into a running session.
    Claude Code's channels docs, which mark channels as a research preview that pushes messages into a running session.

    来源:code.claude.com核对于

  6. 6. Hostinger Managed OpenClaw

    Keeping OpenClaw itself, running 24/7, for the least money
    Hostinger's Managed OpenClaw page, showing $4.99 a month against a struck-out $21.99 and a 30-day money-back guarantee.
    Hostinger's Managed OpenClaw page, showing $4.99 a month against a struck-out $21.99 and a 30-day money-back guarantee.

    来源:hostinger.com核对于

    Hostinger sells OpenClaw two ways: Managed OpenClaw, a one-click instance with AI credits that Hostinger keeps updated and backed up, and a VPS with a one-click OpenClaw Docker template and root access. It is the same OpenClaw software, so it removes the server work but not OpenClaw's skill and permission risks.

    最便宜的付费方案

    $4.99 a month at first, then $11.99 a month

    Managed OpenClaw, paid upfront for the plan term; the page shows it as 77% off $21.99. The VPS template starts at $6.49 a month (renewing at $11.99) with your own model key.

    来源:hostinger.com核对于

    免费额度

    None; 30-day money-back guarantee

    来源:hostinger.com核对于

    Safety defaults

    An isolated environment and a security gateway, per Hostinger

    OpenClaw's own sandbox and skill settings still apply; no audit of the hosting is published.

    来源:hostinger.com核对于

    Chat apps

    Telegram and WhatsApp at setup; Slack and Discord in the FAQ

    来源:hostinger.com核对于

    Models

    Hostinger's AI credits, or your own key on the VPS

    The managed plan needs no API key; the VPS template connects Anthropic, OpenAI or Google with your own key.

    来源:hostinger.com核对于

    优点

    • The cheapest managed OpenClaw found: $4.99 a month for the first term, with AI credits in the same dashboard.
    • Live in about 60 seconds, per Hostinger, with updates and backups handled for you.
    • The VPS option keeps root access if you want to harden OpenClaw yourself.

    要注意

    • Prices more than double at renewal and are paid upfront.
    • It is still OpenClaw, with the same skill and permission risks.
    • Hostinger's own guide to OpenClaw alternatives recommends its hosting without a conflict-of-interest note.

    这些情况别选:you are leaving OpenClaw because of its security model: this is the same software.

    Hostinger's one-click OpenClaw VPS page, from $6.49 a month.
    Hostinger's one-click OpenClaw VPS page, from $6.49 a month.

    来源:hostinger.com核对于

  7. 7. MaxClaw

    Non-technical users who want an OpenClaw agent in Telegram in seconds
    MiniMax's MaxClaw page: deploy in about 10 seconds with no server, Docker or API key, reached from Telegram, Discord and Slack.
    MiniMax's MaxClaw page: deploy in about 10 seconds with no server, Docker or API key, reached from Telegram, Discord and Slack.

    来源:agent.minimax.io核对于

    MaxClaw is MiniMax's hosted OpenClaw: one click on the MiniMax Agent platform deploys an always-on agent with long-term memory and built-in image, video, browser and file tools, which you reach from Telegram, Discord or Slack. There are no servers or API keys, but it runs only on MiniMax's own models.

    最便宜的付费方案

    $19 a month, as shown on the MaxClaw page

    The page does not say what the price includes or how much use it covers.

    来源:agent.minimax.io核对于

    免费额度

    Free MiniMax Agent credits for logging in daily

    No MaxClaw trial is named, and the daily amount is not published.

    来源:agent.minimax.io核对于

    Safety defaults

    Not described

    The MaxClaw page names no sandbox, skill vetting or audit; MiniMax handles hosting and updates.

    来源:agent.minimax.io核对于

    Chat apps

    Telegram, Discord and Slack

    Plus web and mobile.

    来源:agent.minimax.io核对于

    Models

    MiniMax M2.7 only

    You cannot bring your own model.

    来源:agent.minimax.io核对于

    优点

    • The fastest start: MiniMax says it deploys in about 10 seconds with no server, Docker or API key.
    • Image and video generation, a browser and file tools are built in.
    • Taskade's roundup called it the most accessible managed OpenClaw.

    要注意

    • Locked to MiniMax's models.
    • The MiniMax Agent privacy policy does not say whether your tasks train models, and the terms give MiniMax a perpetual licence to your content.
    • MaxClaw is missing from MiniMax's docs and changelog, where the focus has moved to the MiniMax Code desktop app.

    这些情况别选:you need to choose your model, keep data away from a China-headquartered vendor, or see how the agent is secured.

  8. 8. MyClaw

    Running OpenClaw or Hermes 24/7 without touching a server
    MyClaw's pricing page on yearly billing: Lite at $16.6 a month ($199 a year) against $29 billed monthly.
    MyClaw's pricing page on yearly billing: Lite at $16.6 a month ($199 a year) against $29 billed monthly.

    来源:myclaw.ai核对于

    MyClaw is a managed host that runs OpenClaw, Hermes Agent, Claude Code or Codex on a private always-on server for you, with one-click deploy, automatic updates and daily backups. You can switch between OpenClaw and Hermes on the same server, but its terms do not name the company behind it, and model usage is billed on top of hosting.

    最便宜的付费方案

    $29 a month (Lite), or $199 a year

    2 vCPU, 4 GB RAM and 40 GB SSD; AI tokens are not included. The page's own structured data lists Lite at $19, so the price shown may change.

    来源:myclaw.ai核对于

    免费额度

    No free plan or trial shown

    来源:myclaw.ai核对于

    Safety defaults

    A private, encrypted instance, per MyClaw

    No sandbox details, audit or certification are published.

    来源:myclaw.ai核对于

    Chat apps

    Telegram, WhatsApp, email and browser

    Its privacy policy also describes Slack.

    来源:myclaw.ai核对于

    Operator

    Not named

    The terms name only 'MyClaw.ai', under Delaware law.

    来源:myclaw.ai核对于

    优点

    • Runs OpenClaw and Hermes Agent, so you can switch agents without a new server.
    • Ready in about 30 seconds, per MyClaw, with no command line.
    • Yearly billing cuts the price by 43% to 58%.

    要注意

    • The company behind it is not named in its terms or privacy policy.
    • Prices conflict: the visible page shows $29 and $59, while the page's structured data says $19 and $39.
    • Costs more than a plain VPS, and model tokens come on top.

    这些情况别选:you need to know which company holds your data, or you want the cheapest always-on option.

    MyClaw's home page, which advertises a 30-second launch with no setup.
    MyClaw's home page, which advertises a 30-second launch with no setup.

    来源:myclaw.ai核对于

我们核对过的事实

直接列出,每条都注明来源和最近一次核对时间。

事实数值来源
Trail of Bits audited OpenClaw's permissions and user-data handling and reported 24 issues (0 critical, 2 high); all actionable issues were fixed in 2026.8.1 and 2026.7.33 LTS.

来源:openclaw.ai核对于

Four chained OpenClaw CVEs, including a sandbox escape rated CVSS 9.6, were disclosed in May 2026 and fixed in version 2026.4.22.

来源:thehackernews.com核对于

In Kilo's analysis of 25 r/openclaw threads, about 35% of commenters stayed with OpenClaw, 30% had moved to Hermes Agent, 20% ran both and 15% distrusted Hermes.

来源:kilo.ai核对于

Hermes Agent's Skills Guard had an injection flaw, CVE-2026-9353 (CVSS 7.3, public exploit), in versions before 0.15.0.

来源:advisories.gitlab.com核对于

ZeroClaw's maintainers say only github.com/zeroclaw-labs/zeroclaw is official and that other repositories and domains using the name impersonate the project.

来源:github.com核对于

On October 25, 2026 Kilo's public KiloClaw pages redirected to Kilo's home page, with no shutdown or rename announcement found.

来源:kilo.ai核对于

操作步骤

每一步只做一件事。

  1. Back up your OpenClaw setup

    Copy your config, memory files and the list of skills you rely on before you change anything. Hermes can read an OpenClaw setup directly; the other options here start from scratch.

  2. Preview the move before you run it

    In Hermes, run hermes import-agent openclaw with --dry-run first to see what will move, and add --migrate-secrets only once the preview looks right.

  3. Give the new agent new keys

    Create fresh API keys and chat-app tokens for the new agent and revoke the ones OpenClaw held, especially if you ran third-party skills from ClawHub.

  4. Lock it down before you connect chat apps

    Allowlist who may message the agent, keep approvals on for shell commands and give it only the folders it needs. NanoClaw and ZeroClaw sandbox by default; in OpenClaw and nanobot you set that up yourself.

  5. Install from the official source only

    Use each project's own site or GitHub organisation. ZeroClaw's official repository is zeroclaw-labs/zeroclaw, and a MaxClaw domain named in older guides now redirects to a third party.

  6. Watch the model bill for the first week

    An always-on agent calls its model all day. Check your provider's usage page after a few days and set a spending limit before costs surprise you.

How we ranked these alternatives

People searching for an OpenClaw alternative want one of three things: a safer or lighter agent they still run themselves, OpenClaw without the server work, or an always-on assistant from a company. Each option here was placed on its safety defaults, how much setup it takes, which chat apps it answers in, which models it can use and what that costs, how actively it is maintained, and how easily an existing OpenClaw setup moves over. Every fact was read on the project's own pages or the sources linked on this page on October 25, 2026. For open-source projects, GitHub stars stand in for how widely they are used.

Hermes Agent is first because the switching conversation ends up there most often, it is safer than OpenClaw out of the box, and it imports an OpenClaw setup with one command. NanoClaw and ZeroClaw come next for putting safety first by default. The hosted options sit lower because they either keep OpenClaw's own risks or tie you to one vendor.

Why people leave OpenClaw, and the case for staying

Kilo's reading of more than 1,300 comments in 25 r/openclaw threads found the same complaints again and again: updates that break working setups, memory that cannot be relied on, the effort of hosting it yourself, and security. The security record is real. In early 2026 Koi Security counted 341 malicious skills among 2,857 on ClawHub, with payloads that stole macOS credentials and crypto wallets (Bitdoze's summary). In May, four chained CVEs, including a sandbox escape rated 9.6, were fixed in version 2026.4.22 (The Hacker News). And OpenClaw still runs tools on the host for the main session unless you turn sandboxing on (its README).

There is also a case for staying. A Trail of Bits audit published on September 21, 2026 found 24 issues, none critical, all fixed in 2026.8.1 and the 2026.7.33 LTS release. Every upload to ClawHub is now scanned by NVIDIA's and Tencent's tools before an AI judge decides (ClawScan), the OpenClaw Foundation runs the project as a non-profit, a free OpenClaw Enterprise is in the works, and Microsoft built its Autopilot preview on it (announcement). In Kilo's sample, about 35% of commenters were staying put.

Which kind of alternative you need

  • A lighter or safer agent you run yourself (Hermes Agent, NanoClaw, ZeroClaw, nanobot): free software, your own model key, your own machine. NanoClaw and ZeroClaw sandbox by default, Hermes gates risky commands, and nanobot relies on allowlists. A third-party estimate puts the model bill at about $5 to $15 a month for light use on a cheap model, and hundreds for heavy, always-on use of premium models (eesel).
  • OpenClaw itself, hosted for you (Hostinger, MaxClaw, MyClaw): no server work, but the same OpenClaw underneath, with its skill and permission model. MaxClaw also ties you to MiniMax's models.
  • A company's agent (Claude Cowork): nothing to host or secure, a monthly subscription, one vendor's models, and no WhatsApp or Telegram for Cowork itself.

OpenClaw hosting options

If you only want OpenClaw running 24/7 without managing a server, Hostinger's Managed OpenClaw is the cheapest found, at $4.99 a month for the first term and $11.99 after that. MyClaw starts at $29 a month and also runs Hermes, and MaxClaw costs $19 a month on MiniMax's models. Nous Research offers one-click hosted Hermes through Nous Portal, with server costs billed to your credit balance. None of these changes OpenClaw's own security model, so the switching steps on this page still apply.

What public comparisons show

No independent test has run these agents side by side on the same everyday tasks. The closest is WildClawBench, a May 2026 paper that ran 60 long, real-tool tasks through OpenClaw, Claude Code, Codex and Hermes with 19 models. The best score, 62.2% for Claude Opus 4.7, came under OpenClaw, and changing only the harness moved one model's score by up to 18 points. A secondary summary says Hermes was the best harness for three of four models; the paper itself was too large to check that claim.

Most roundups are written by companies with something to sell. Composio recommends Hermes for the closest match, NanoClaw for isolation and Claude Cowork for the easiest start, while hosting its own TrustClaw. openclawvps.io, which sells OpenClaw hosting, scored OpenClaw 22 of 25, ZeroClaw and nanobot 20 and NanoClaw 16, with NanoClaw top on security and bottom on setup. Sphere, an Anthropic and AWS partner that says so, advises choosing by blast radius rather than features and calls raw self-hosted OpenClaw unfit for companies without security staff. Turing Post suggests Hermes for a long-running agent with clean defaults and OpenClaw for manual control, and notes that you can run both.

Other tools we looked at

  • KiloClaw, Kilo's hosted OpenClaw: on October 25, 2026 its public pages redirected to Kilo's home page and no announcement explained why, so it is not ranked. Its launch post is from February 2026.
  • Kimi Claw, Moonshot AI's hosted OpenClaw: a Chinese-language internal beta that comes with Kimi's paid memberships (kimi.com).
  • PicoClaw, a Go agent for very small hardware: its maintainers say not to use it in production before version 1.0 (GitHub).
  • IronClaw, NEAR AI's Rust agent that runs tools in WebAssembly sandboxes: security-focused, but smaller, with about 12.7k GitHub stars, and without WhatsApp or iMessage (GitHub).

这些工具的共同短板

它们还做不好的地方和证据,以及公开测试还没定论的地方。

做得不好

做得不好

  • Any agent can misuse the access you give it.

    证据: Anthropic's Cowork help page says isolation does not limit what Claude does with access you grant, and OpenClaw's own sandbox is off for the main session by default.

  • The light forks are young.

    证据: ZeroClaw is at version 0.8, PicoClaw's maintainers say not to use it in production before 1.0, and VentureBeat noted NanoClaw's security claims have no independent audit.

  • Most published comparisons come from companies that sell one of the options.

    证据: Composio hosts TrustClaw, Hostinger and openclawvps.io sell OpenClaw hosting, Kilo sold KiloClaw, and Taskade ranks itself first.

尚不确定

尚不确定

  • Which agent gets the best results from the same model.

    原因: WildClawBench found the harness alone moved one model's score by up to 18 points, with the best single score under OpenClaw; a summary saying Hermes led for three of four models could not be checked against the paper.

  • Whether KiloClaw still exists as a product.

    原因: Its public pages redirect to Kilo's home page and no announcement was found; the sign-in app route still exists.

常见问题

先给结论,再讲原因、例子、限制和下一步。

What is the best OpenClaw alternative?

For most people leaving OpenClaw, Hermes Agent: it is free and MIT-licensed, safer by default, and imports an OpenClaw setup with one command. Pick NanoClaw if you want every session in a container, ZeroClaw for a tiny sandboxed binary on cheap hardware, and Claude Cowork if you would rather pay a subscription than run a server.

Is Hermes Agent better than OpenClaw?

Hermes Agent has safer defaults and easier setup than OpenClaw, while OpenClaw has more chat apps and more manual control. Hermes asks before dangerous commands and denies chat users until you allowlist them; OpenClaw runs tools on the host unless you set up its sandbox. In Kilo's sample of r/openclaw comments, about 30% had moved to Hermes, 20% ran both and 35% stayed. Hermes had its own injection flaw, CVE-2026-9353, until version 0.15.0.

Is there a safer alternative to OpenClaw?

Yes: NanoClaw and ZeroClaw are the safest by default. NanoClaw runs every session in its own Docker container and keeps API keys in a vault the agent never sees; ZeroClaw asks before medium-risk actions, blocks high-risk ones and runs inside an OS sandbox. No independent audit of either was found, and both still act on whatever accounts and folders you connect.

Can I run OpenClaw without my own server?

Yes, through a managed host. Hostinger's Managed OpenClaw costs $4.99 a month for the first term and $11.99 after that, MyClaw starts at $29 a month, and MiniMax's MaxClaw costs $19 a month on MiniMax models. They remove the server work but run the same OpenClaw, with the same skill and permission risks.

Can I move my OpenClaw setup to another agent?

Hermes Agent can import it directly with hermes import-agent openclaw, using --dry-run to preview and --migrate-secrets to bring keys across. The other alternatives here start from scratch, so copy your config, memory files and list of skills first, and create new API keys for the new agent.

Is OpenClaw safe to use in 2026?

OpenClaw is safer than it was, but not safe by default. A Trail of Bits audit in September 2026 found 24 issues, none critical, all fixed, and ClawHub uploads are now scanned; but the sandbox stays off for the main session unless you turn it on, and hundreds of malicious skills were found on ClawHub earlier in the year. Turn on sandboxing, allowlist who can message it, and install skills only after reading them.

来源

来源

  1. Hermes Agent home page (hermes-agent.nousresearch.com), 访问于
  2. Nous Portal plans (portal.nousresearch.com), 访问于
  3. Hermes Agent on GitHub (github.com), 访问于
  4. Hermes Agent docs: security (hermes-agent.nousresearch.com), 访问于
  5. NanoClaw home page (nanoclaw.dev), 访问于
  6. NanoClaw on GitHub (github.com), 访问于
  7. ZeroClaw official site (zeroclaw.com), 访问于
  8. ZeroClaw on GitHub (zeroclaw-labs) (github.com), 访问于
  9. nanobot on GitHub (HKUDS) (github.com), 访问于
  10. Claude Cowork product page (claude.com), 访问于
  11. Claude pricing (claude.com), 访问于
  12. Claude help: get started with Cowork (support.claude.com), 访问于
  13. Claude Code docs: channels (code.claude.com), 访问于
  14. Hostinger Managed OpenClaw (hostinger.com), 访问于
  15. Hostinger one-click OpenClaw VPS (hostinger.com), 访问于
  16. MiniMax MaxClaw page (agent.minimax.io), 访问于
  17. MyClaw home page (myclaw.ai), 访问于
  18. MyClaw pricing (myclaw.ai), 访问于
  19. MyClaw terms (myclaw.ai), 访问于
  20. OpenClaw: Trail of Bits engagement recap (September 21, 2026) (openclaw.ai), 访问于
  21. The Hacker News: four OpenClaw flaws enable data theft (May 2026) (thehackernews.com), 访问于
  22. Kilo: OpenClaw vs Hermes, from 1,300+ r/openclaw comments (kilo.ai), 访问于
  23. GitLab advisory: CVE-2026-9353 in hermes-agent (advisories.gitlab.com), 访问于
  24. Kilo: KiloClaw page (redirects to Kilo's home page) (kilo.ai), 访问于
  25. OpenClaw on GitHub (github.com), 访问于
  26. OpenClaw: Tencent AIG joins ClawScan (October 2, 2026) (openclaw.ai), 访问于
  27. OpenClaw Enterprise announcement (September 29, 2026) (openclaw.ai), 访问于
  28. OpenClaw: Microsoft Autopilot built on OpenClaw (September 25, 2026) (openclaw.ai), 访问于
  29. OpenClaw Foundation launch (July 8, 2026) (openclaw.ai), 访问于
  30. Bitdoze: OpenClaw security guide (bitdoze.com), 访问于
  31. eesel: OpenClaw pricing and running costs (eesel.ai), 访问于
  32. Turing Post: Hermes Agent (turingpost.com), 访问于
  33. openclawvps.io: OpenClaw alternatives scored (March 2026) (openclawvps.io), 访问于
  34. Composio: OpenClaw alternatives (September 2026) (composio.dev), 访问于
  35. Sphere: OpenClaw alternatives for enterprises (July 2026) (sphereinc.com), 访问于
  36. Kilo blog: KiloClaw, hosted OpenClaw (February 2026) (blog.kilo.ai), 访问于
  37. Kimi Claw (Moonshot AI) (kimi.com), 访问于
  38. PicoClaw on GitHub (Sipeed) (github.com), 访问于
  39. IronClaw on GitHub (NEAR AI) (github.com), 访问于
  40. WildClawBench (arXiv 2605.10912, May 2026) (arxiv.org), 访问于
  41. OpenClaw home page (openclaw.ai), 访问于
  42. Wikipedia: OpenClaw (en.wikipedia.org), 访问于
  43. OpenClaw docs: OpenClaw and Hermes Agent (docs.openclaw.ai), 访问于
  44. Pasquale Pillitteri: Hermes Agent community opinions (pasqualepillitteri.it), 访问于
  45. Standard Compute: r/openclaw thread on alternatives (May 2026) (standardcompute.com), 访问于
  46. VentureBeat: NanoClaw and OpenClaw's security issues (February 2026) (venturebeat.com), 访问于
  47. TechCrunch: NanoClaw's creator and the Docker deal (March 13, 2026) (techcrunch.com), 访问于
  48. awesome-openclaw-alternatives (GitHub list) (github.com), 访问于
  49. nanobot releases (github.com), 访问于
  50. KDnuggets: lightweight OpenClaw alternatives (February 2026) (kdnuggets.com), 访问于
  51. Hostinger: OpenClaw alternatives guide (hostinger.com), 访问于
  52. MiniMax Agent privacy policy (agent.minimax.io), 访问于
  53. MiniMax Agent changelog (agent.minimax.io), 访问于
  54. eesel: MaxClaw guide (March 2026) (eesel.ai), 访问于
  55. Taskade: best OpenClaw alternatives (taskade.com), 访问于
  56. MyClaw privacy policy (myclaw.ai), 访问于
  57. HackerNoon: OpenClaw security and alternatives (March 2026) (hackernoon.com), 访问于

更新记录

更新记录

  1. List created from public sources: licences, safety defaults, chat apps, prices and GitHub stars read on each project's own pages.

GenGrades 推荐阅读

  • 工具评测

    VideoEnhancer

    VideoEnhancer is a web tool that upscales short MP4 clips to 1080p, 2K or 4K with the FlashVSR model and also compresses, face-swaps and generates video. After a 5-second free trial, 1080p costs 3 credits a second, $0.03 to $0.09 depending on how credits are bought. VideoEnhancer is our own product: it is made by the team behind GenGrades.

  • 工具评测

    LayerGrab

    LayerGrab splits a flat image into up to 16 named, transparent layers over a filled-in background, on the web, in Figma or in Chrome, or pulls out only what you name. Each layer costs $0.10 on its $12 plan, $0.08 on Premium. No independent review exists yet. LayerGrab is our own product: it is made by the team behind GenGrades.

  • 工具评测

    VideoTextRemover

    VideoTextRemover is a web tool that erases burned-in subtitles, captions and other on-screen text from MP4 and MOV videos and repaints what was behind them, up to 1080p. It bills per second processed, about $0.025 to $0.049, with 30 free seconds a month in some countries. VideoTextRemover is our own product: it is made by the team behind GenGrades.

  • 工具评测

    MagicRemover

    MagicRemover is a browser tool that erases people, objects, text, logos and watermarks from photos, and subtitles from videos. Photos get 2 free removals a day, 2 more after sign-in, at about 1 megapixel; beyond that, credits start at $9.90 for 330. MagicRemover is our own product: it is made by the team behind GenGrades.